The rise of the internet has allowed for collaborative creative projects on an unprecedented scale.[1] People from all over the world can come together to create, remix, and develop one coherent and deeply complex fictional world. Big-name Hollywood studios such as A24 have begun to take notice and develop these internet-native stories for the silver screen.[2] Following the success of Backrooms, two different studios have announced their plans to create a film based on the SCP Foundation, a collaborative online horror-writing project that is constantly evolving.[3] Such endeavors do not come without complications: the underlying creative works of these horror communities are governed by open licenses that restrict later proprietary control.[4] This raises tension with Hollywood’s current model of exclusivity and private ownership. The current SCP controversy demonstrates a growing mismatch between traditional entertainment licensing and internet-native collaborative projects: Creative Commons licenses allow commercially valuable fictional worlds to develop without centralized ownership, but that same decentralized structure prevents later entrants from obtaining the exclusivity on which conventional entertainment business models often rely.
The Legal Groundwork for Copyright and CC Licensing
The origins and underlying justification of copyright law lie in Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 of the Constitution: “To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.”[5] Using the powers vested by the Intellectual Property Clause, Congress enacted 17 U.S.C. section 106, which outlines the exclusive rights and authorities granted to creators of copyrightable works.[6] The rights authorized by the statute include (1) reproduction, (2) derivative works, (3) distribution, (4) public performance, (5) public display, and (6) public digital audio transmission.[7] The rights vested in copyright holders are extensive, but limited in duration for a set period of years.[8] In essence, holding a copyright means having the exclusive right to legally control how one’s own original creative works are used and shared by others.
However, not all creators want to exercise the full breadth of the rights afforded to them.[9] Many creatives endorse a more public policy vision of copyright, stemming from a joint belief in the importance of freedom to reference, transform, and exchange ideas.[10] In 2002, these ideologies led to the foundation of the Creative Commons, an international nonprofit organization dedicated to providing freely accessible copyright licenses designed for open access and collaboration.[11] Without the availability of these public licenses, copyrights can often feel restricted to either “all rights reserved” or “no rights reserved.”[12] Creative Commons licenses provide an in-between for creatives to maintain some quintessential rights, while allowing for a more open exchange of subsequent ideas and collaboration.[13]
The Creative Commons provides six different types of licenses to the public, which range in levels of permissibility.[14] In order of most to least permissible, the licenses are as follows: (1) Attribution (CC BY), (2) Attribution-ShareAlike (CC BY-SA), (3) Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC), (4) Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike (CC BY-NC-SA), (5) Attribution-NoDerivatives (CC BY-ND), and (6) Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives (CC BY-NC-ND).[15] The licenses are composed of four key elements—Attribution, NonCommercial, ShareAlike, and NoDerivatives.[16] Attribution is the only element shared by every type of license; it requires that any licensee provide sufficient credit to the original creator and licensor.[17] NonCommercial licenses require that any subsequent uses of the work by the licensee be noncommercial in nature.[18] The ShareAlike label requires that any subsequent derivative works produced by the licensee be governed by identical licensing to the original licensor’s work.[19] NoDerivative licensing means that licensees can only copy, display, perform, and distribute the original work as is, without creating derivative versions.[20]
The various combinations of these elements allow copyright holders to be selective in retaining specific rights while granting broad collaborative power to licensees, usually the general public.[21] CC BY-SA licenses are particularly well suited for online writing projects that fundamentally depend on community collaboration.[22] As a licensee, it is important to take note of ShareAlike’s requirements around derivative works and ensuring any subsequent licensing follows the same format as the original licensor’s work.[23] With that in mind, Hollywood’s growing interest in online community projects has raised new questions about the compatibility of traditional entertainment business models with the ownership and creative norms of internet-native projects.[24]
Internet-Native Projects Enter Hollywood
Shortly after the foundation of the Creative Commons, big online creative communities began to form using the provided license models.[25] Today, billions of works have been released under CC licenses.[26] Some of the biggest platforms that utilize CC licensing include YouTube, Wikipedia, Wikimedia Commons, Flickr, and Vimeo.[27] Fictional horror projects in particular have also grown and flourished on these platforms as specifically internet-native, highly collaborative creative works.[28]
Some of the most notable online horror projects include the SCP Foundation and the Backrooms, both of which are licensed under CC BY-SA.[29] Both projects depend on the contributions of independent writers and creatives to expand and give life to their respective universes.[30] The SCP Foundation is for the most part a writing collaboration, where authors create “SCP” (fictional entities, objects, or phenomena that defy scientific explanation) and write from the perspective of fictional, in-universe researchers trying to understand uniquely anomalous creatures and phenomena.[31] Similarly, the Backrooms is centered on an in-universe phenomenon called “the Backrooms,” a seemingly infinite liminal space that constantly evolves and contradicts itself.[32] Since their creation, both projects have grown into large online communities, with contributors and fans participating in their collaborative fictional universes.[33] Given the widespread online popularity of these communities, it is unsurprising that Hollywood studios eventually turned their attention toward adapting internet-native works for film.[34]
The Backrooms was the first of its kind to receive a hit movie adaptation from popular indie film studio A24.[35] A24 was able to avoid some CC BY-SA licensing complications by adapting Kane Parsons’ distinct depiction of the Backrooms rather than works from the Backrooms Wiki.[36] Parsons is a self-taught filmmaker and visual effects artist who began making Backrooms videos on YouTube in 2022.[37] A24’s adaptation of Parsons’ unique depiction of the Backrooms has been accompanied by heavily relaxed moderation of Backrooms media online.[38] The film was massively successful, grossing $400.07 million globally ($197.5 million domestic and $202.57 million internationally) against a $10 million budget.[39] However, following the film’s release, A24 has drawn criticism for issuing numerous automated takedown notices of legitimate Backrooms fan-made content.[40] Despite Parsons’ assurances that the studio would preserve the project’s open-access nature, notable tensions remain between deeply rooted internet-native projects and traditional Hollywood.[41] Many Hollywood studios have taken notice of an exploding demand for niche internet-native content and have raced to begin production.[42] Subsequently, A24 and NEON, a competing indie horror studio, both announced in September 2026 their intention to begin filming movies based on the SCP Foundation.[43]
The SCP Foundation: A Case of ShareAlike Complications
Unlike the Backrooms, the SCP Foundation has no clear alternative for studios looking to receive specialized licensing.[44] Any studio looking to create a film of the Foundation would be acting as a licensee creating a ShareAlike derivative work under CC BY-SA.[45] Thus far, NEON and A24 have taken contrasting approaches to the underlying copyright in the project.[46] The SCP Foundation wiki put out a statement announcing that A24 has not currently consulted any staff regarding their film adaptation and logistics.[47] In contrast, staff has confirmed NEON is working closely with staff to produce a film that strictly adheres to the Foundation’s CC BY-SA licensing restrictions.[48]
With both films, there will be significant and unique challenges in creating a traditional Hollywood film under ShareAlike derivative works licensing.[49] Any studio using proper attribution and CC BY-SA licensing would be able to legally create a derivative film, distribute it to theaters, stream it, and commercially profit.[50] However, there are industry standards in Hollywood that are incompatible with this model of CC license.[51] For example, the studios would “not be permitted to distribute the film with DRM or other effective technological measures that would prevent it from being copied.”[52] In modern film, it is essentially unheard of for a large Hollywood film to be produced without DRM.[53] DRM uses encryption and other technological controls to restrict unauthorized access, copying, and redistribution of copyrighted film.[54] This directly contradicts the open access model that CC licensing requires of its licensees.
Additionally, film studios would not be able to establish exclusivity in the chain of distribution.[55] The Foundation confirmed, “Just as anyone who follows the license can redistribute and create derivative works based on the SCP Foundation articles on [the] wiki, anyone will be able to do the same with their film.”[56] Essentially, any interested party could upload the entire derivative film to YouTube without any payment to the studio or wiki as long as there was sufficient attribution.[57] Studios would additionally be unable to contractually prevent theatres from making copies of and distributing the film.[58] If a licensee violates these terms, they would lose the rights in their derivative work connecting to the underlying SCP Foundation.[59] This puts a huge strain on interested parties and raises the question: is a Hollywood film worth it?
A Tension Between Private and Public Visions of Creativity
To a prospective filmmaker, the aforementioned drawbacks of ShareAlike works are substantial. Hollywood films are expensive; profitability requires significant revenue. The exclusivity of theatrical showings and streaming subscriptions has become commonplace in modern film economics.[60] This structure depends on a private vision of ownership: creators should enjoy exclusive rights to their work, especially its financial gain. Blockbuster filmmaking has long blurred the line between creation for joy and monetary gain. When the Framers wrote the Copyright Clause into the Constitution, was this the future they envisioned? One where art is highly monetized, exclusive, and controlled? Courts must strike a balance between protecting artists’ rights and safeguarding the free flow of ideas.[61] There are incentives on both sides.
Creative Commons licenses endorse a theory opposite to current Hollywood momentum: the value of creative works lies in a public vision of art.[62] In a recent survey of 280 copyright holders whose works are licensed under CC, 71.8% said their primary motivation to create was “love of creating/inner desire to create/fun/hobby.”[63] Only 1.8% identified financial gain as their primary motivation.[64] The commercial constraints that pose significant challenges for major studios are the core reasons the internet community gravitates towards this form of open licensing.[65] This public approach to ownership quintessentially promotes the progress of the arts.
In this vision, the commons are raw creative material for future generations of creators.[66] The bounds of ownership are stripped away, and free creativity can flow in its most organic form. There is a multiplier of progress that is expounded upon every time a work is licensed under Creative Commons.[67] Genuine creative endeavors can exponentially multiply and become far more than they ever would have been under traditional licensing. No internet-native collaborative work would exist in its current form without a steady inflow of additions from unique artists and creators.[68] ShareAlike licensing centrally endorses this theory, as it prevents downstream creators from exploiting and appropriating all the free contributions of prior collaborators.[69]
This paradox, the openness that makes creative projects like the SCP Foundation so commercially difficult, is exactly what creates their inherent commercial value. Huge collaborative universes with constantly amassing derivative creations have been shown to massively entice the public.[70] It provides a sense of community, an ability to contribute to something bigger, and an opportunity to connect on a deeper creative level. The barriers to entry are lowered, thereby incentivizing contribution from even inexperienced creators.[71] This, in its essence, is why Hollywood continues to pursue these internet-native projects.[72] The way these works are built creates an extremely valuable and evidently attractive market for film studios. These projects have well-developed fictional universes, cultivated, involved fandoms, and high levels of audience demand.[73] Little research needs to be done to show these works will very likely be successful at the box office—and Backrooms is proof of that concept.[74] These internet-native stories are especially well received by younger audiences, a demographic Hollywood is continuously searching for new ways to attract.[75]
As the internet continues to grow exponentially, copyright theory and its justifications are repeatedly tested. While Creative Commons makes a strong argument for a public vision of ownership, its dependence on traditional copyright cannot be overstated.[76] While traditional copyright depends on exclusivity as an incentive for creative production, CC licensing necessarily utilizes that exclusivity in the alternative: it gives creators the legal power to choose openness. The legal ability to relinquish portions of exclusivity is what allows the openness to propagate and multiply downstream.[77]
So, Is a Hollywood Film Really Worth It?
There is an untapped wealth of uniquely rich creative projects living on the internet, born from human-to-human interaction in digital spaces such as YouTube, wiki pages, and Reddit posts. If Hollywood studios like NEON are willing to shed the traditional exclusivity-dependent model that has become entrenched in the mainstream film industry, there is significant potential to create unparalleled artistic and commercial value while developing devoted communities of creatives. Only time will tell how such endeavors impact our current film industry—and how we approach copyright and ownership in this ever-evolving digital era.
[1] Minjeong Kim, The Creative Commons and Copyright Protection in the Digital Era: Uses of Creative Commons Licenses, 13 J. Comput.-Mediated Commc’n 187, 199 (2007).
[2] Cerys Davies, Hollywood’s big online bet: Inside the industry’s race to acquire internet stories, L.A. TIMES (July 8, 2026, 7:00 PM GMT), https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/movies/articles/hollywoods-big-online-bet-inside-100000566.html.
[3] Matt Grobar, A24 Boards SCP Foundation Movie From Spooky Pictures & Image Nation, Sets 2027 Release, DEADLINE (Sept. 11, 2026, 2:00 PM), https://deadline.com/2026/09/scp-foundation-movie-a24-theaters-2027-1237099512/; Statement on NEON Film, SCP Found. (last updated Oct. 8, 2026), https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/statement-on-neon-film.
[4] Licensing Guide, SCP Found. (Sept. 12, 2026), https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/licensing-guide; Licensing Guide, The Backrooms, https://backrooms-wiki.wikidot.com/licensing-guide (last updated Nov. 3, 2026).
[5] U.S. Const. art. I, § 8, cl. 8.
[6] 17 U.S.C. § 106 (1976).
[7] Id.
[8] U.S. Const. art. I, § 8, cl. 8.
[9] Chad A. Rutkowski, Creative Commons Licensing 1 (Practical Guidance, LexisNexis, current as of Apr. 8, 2024).
[10] Kim, supra note 1, at 190–91.
[11] Sharing Openly, Sharing Globally, creative commons, https://creativecommons.org/cc-licenses/ (last visited Oct. 1, 2026).
[12] Id.
[13] Id.
[14] Id.
[15] Id.; Rutkowski, supra note 9, at 2–3.
[16] Kim, supra note 1, at 192–93.
[17] Rutkowski, supra note 9, at 2.
[18] Sharing Openly, Sharing Globally, supra note 11.
[19] Id.
[20] Id.
[21] Id.
[22] Kim, supra note 1, at 201.
[23] Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International Public License § 3(b)(1), creative commons, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/legalcode.en (last visited Oct. 2, 2026).
[24] Davies, supra note 2.
[25] Kim, supra note 1, at 199–200.
[26] Sharing Openly, Sharing Globally, supra note 11.
[27] Id.
[28] Alex Weprin, ‘Backrooms’ Sends Hollywood Running to Reddit for New Ideas, The Hollywood Rep. (June 16, 2026, 5:15 AM), https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/digital/reddit-backrooms-hollywood-ip-1236622594/; Chrishaun Baker, How Will the Wave of Internet Horror Movies Deal with Fan Artists?, Inverse (July 22, 2026), https://www.inverse.com/entertainment/backrooms-copyright-creepypasta-issues.
[29] Licensing Guide, supra note 4 (SCP Foundation); Licensing Guide, supra note 4 (The Backrooms).
[30] Weprin, supra note 28; Baker, supra note 28.
[31] About the SCP Foundation, SCP Found. (June 18, 2026), https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/about-the-scp-foundation.
[32] The Backrooms Wiki, The Backrooms, https://backrooms-wiki.wikidot.com (last visited Oct. 2, 2026).
[33] Weprin, supra note 28.
[34] Davies, supra note 2.
[35] Baker, supra note 28.
[36] Carlos Aguilar, Kane Parsons Is 20. Here’s How He Made A24’s Biggest Summer Movie, the Spooky ‘Backrooms’, L.A. Times (May 14, 2026, 3:00 AM PT), https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/movies/story/2026-05-14/kane-parsons-backrooms-a24-renate-reinsve-chiwetel-ejiofor-horror-summer-preview-2026; Licensing Guide, supra note 4 (The Backrooms).
[37] Aguilar, supra note 36.
[38] Baker, supra note 28.
[39] Rebecca Rubin, ‘Backrooms’ Surpasses $400 Million at Global Box Office, Variety (Sept. 20, 2026, 7:20 AM PT), https://variety.com/2026/film/box-office/backrooms-box-office-milestone-400-million-1236870141/.
[40] Baker, supra note 28.
[41] Id.
[42] Davies, supra note 2; Weprin, supra note 28.
[43] Grobar, supra note 3; Statement on NEON Film, supra note 3.
[44] Statement on V/H/S SCP Foundation Film, SCP Found. (Sept. 21, 2026), https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/statement-on-vhs-film; Licensing Guide, supra note 4 (SCP Foundation).
[45] Statement on V/H/S SCP Foundation Film, supra note 44.
[46] Statement on V/H/S SCP Foundation Film, supra note 44; Statement on NEON Film, supra note 3.
[47] Statement on V/H/S SCP Foundation Film, supra note 44.
[48] Statement on NEON Film, supra note 3.
[49] Id.
[50] Id.
[51] Statement on V/H/S SCP Foundation Film, supra note 44.
[52] Id.
[53] Jean Navarrete, What Is DRM for Video Protection and Why It Matters in 2025, Castlabs (Feb. 5, 2025), https://castlabs.com/blog/drm-video-protection/.
[54] Id.
[55] Statement on V/H/S SCP Foundation Film, supra note 44.
[56] Id.
[57] Id.
[58] Id.
[59] Id.
[60] Thorsten Hennig-Thurau, S. Abraham Ravid & Olav Sorenson, The Economics of Filmed Entertainment in the Digital Era, 45 J. Cultural Econ. 13, 17–18 (2021).
[61] Kim, supra note 1, at 190–91.
[62] Id.
[63] Id. at 199.
[64] Id.
[65] Id. at 199-201.
[66] Timothy K. Armstrong, Shrinking the Commons: Termination of Copyright Licenses and Transfers for the Benefit of the Public, 47 Harv. J. On Legis. 359, 366–67 (2010).
[67] Id. at 368.
[68] Kim, supra note 1, at 201.
[69] Armstrong, supra note 66, at 373.
[70] Weprin, supra note 28.
[71] Armstrong, supra note 66, at 366; Kim, supra note 1, at 199–201.
[72] Davies, supra note 2.
[73] Weprin, supra note 28.
[74] Rubin, supra note 39.
[75] Todd Spangler, Universal Cable Productions Wants to Turn Wattpad Fan-Fiction Into TV Shows, Variety (Nov. 22, 2016, 9:30 AM PT), https://variety.com/2016/digital/news/wattpad-universal-cable-productions-tv-shows-1201924676/.
[76] Niva Elkin-Koren, What Contracts Cannot Do: The Limits of Private Ordering in Facilitating a Creative Commons, 74 Fordham L. Rev. 375, 399–400 (2005).
[77] Armstrong, supra note 66, at 366–68.